Featured cases

Case: Shipley Energy 2011


2011


THE STORY

Shipley Energy bore the image of a family-owned local heating oil company in rural York County, Pennsylvania. Its logo featured a helicopter, once used for emergency fuel deliveries (but no longer; four-wheel drive and snowmobiles are more cost-effective).  Why rebrand? It's a textbook case of the use of identity change, by a leader, for purposes both strategic (85%) and functional (15%):

1) Strategic broadening:
    "We are changing because today we are no longer just oil. Natural gas now as big as our oil business. Propane gas was not even on the horizon 15 years ago—and Shipley is now a recognized leader in our region. And we continue to push toward a future that includes electricity."
2) Regional expansion:
    "The helicopter served in one county, but we now cover fifteen counties in three states. We want to be seen as regional, not local." 

3)
Brand consolidation & unit cohesion.
    "One central brand idea across our lines of businesses"
4)
Support a culture of dynamism.
    "We're changing because it's what we do. Shipley is constantly reinventing itself [and] the industry"

5) Refresh, renew employee energy...
     "Re-energize the talents and commitment of our caring associates"


In addition, Bill Shipley recognized that the old mark "did not go far enough to represent the Shipley Energy of the present and future."  The design execution did not convey quality and stature. 

Wolf's design solution features an abstract circular symbol plus a strong visual system, whose curved green forms evoke the rolling hills of Shipley country (see vehicle livery at www.identityworks.com.). The resulting visual impression is one of greater stature, and a more evident management presence. 

A new tagline, "Energy For Life," reinforces the company's broader promise.  

The launch event was an arena party for 400 employees and guests with film, music and an unveiling of three vehicles. In his thank you note to Wolf that evening, Bill Shipley said "The space was perfect, the lighting dramatic, the sound outstanding and the rolling back of the curtains made for a spectacular finish. There were ooohs and aaahs and cheering and …wow…the room was transformed by the performance."

So too, let us hope, was the company.


CREDITS

Bob Wolf (Wolf Design Partners) with consultants Russell Völckmann and Patrick Ohlin 


CASE INFO

Submitted by: Tony Spaeth, 28/01/2011
Status: Confirmed by CEO William Shipley III, 25 Jan. 2011
Category: Oil Equipment, Services & Distribution
Country (HQ): United States


MATRIX DATA

DRIVERS

  

TOOLS

Strategic driver: 85%   
Broaden scope/scale/visibility
  Remove limiting category association
 10%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Verbal elements: Tag lines
Broaden scope/scale/visibility
  Remove limiting geographic association
 10%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
Broaden scope/scale/visibility
  Enhance size perception
 10%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Typography
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Graphic devices
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Palette
    x  Change event : Medium visibility: Launch event
Broaden scope/scale/visibility
  Elevate public profile
 10%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Typography
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Graphic devices
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Palette
    x  Identity system elements: Verbal elements: Tag lines
    x  Change event : Medium visibility: Launch event
Change internal culture
  Enhance pride & confidence
 15%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Typography
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Graphic devices
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Palette
    x  Identity system elements: Verbal elements: Tag lines
    x  Change event : Medium visibility: Launch event
Change internal culture
  Refresh & redirect competitive energy
 15%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Typography
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Graphic devices
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Palette
    x  Identity system elements: Verbal elements: Tag lines
    x  Change event : Medium visibility: Launch event
Change expressed personality
  Renew/refresh public image
 10%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Typography
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Graphic devices
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Palette
    x  Identity system elements: Verbal elements: Tag lines
Change perceived composition
  Modify parental 'umbrella' presence
 5%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Typography
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Graphic devices
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Palette
    x  Identity system elements: Verbal elements: Tag lines
    
Functional driver: 15%   
Design weakness
  Increase visual strength/quality
 15%  x  Identifier tactics: Logo change: Symbol-dominant
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Typography
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Graphic devices
    x  Identity system elements: Visual system: Palette